How to Implement Digital Clinical Consultations in UK Maternity Care: the ARM@DA Realist Review

Abstract

Background: Digital transformation is a key component within the National Health Service Maternity Transformation Programme. The COVID-19 pandemic led to an acceleration of digital innovation, in particular, the use of digital clinical consultations (telephone/video consultations). The ways in which digital clinical consultations can be optimised and utilised alongside the traditional maternity care pathway remains unclear, however, with particular concerns about the potential for digital care to exacerbate inequalities.

Objective: To explore how digital clinical consultations can be implemented in a clinically safe, appropriate and acceptable way within UK maternity services? For whom? In what settings? And for what purposes?

Design: A realist synthesis combining an evidence review of diverse sources (2010 to the present) from Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development countries with insights from key stakeholder groups (healthcare professionals, service users and community organisations).

Data sources: There were three main sources: (1) published primary and secondary research; (2) grey literature (such as policy documents and maternity safety reports); and (3) stakeholder insights.

Methods: A realist synthesis adopts a theory-driven approach which seeks to understand how a complex programme works, for whom and under what circumstances. The review had three iterative phases: (1) refining the review focus and developing initial programme theories; (2) retrieval of evidence for data extraction and analysis (using on a realist logic to identify key contexts, mechanisms and outcomes); and (3) testing and refining the programme theories.

Results: The final synthesis included 93 evidence sources (reviews, reports and 77 primary studies), with priority given to UK-focused studies. Study samples included a focus on healthcare professionals (n = 17), women (n = 45, of which 14 focused on vulnerable groups) or both (n = 15). Clinical and safety-related outcomes were reported in 12 studies. Fifteen programme theories were developed. A conceptual framework was produced that illustrates the inter-relationship between key contexts in maternity care through which different interactions activate mechanisms to produce outcomes of interest. The findings suggest that digital clinical consultations can be acceptable and appropriate if implementation includes personalisation and informed choice for women, as well as support and autonomy for staff. The relationship and connection between women and their healthcare professional are proposed as key mechanisms that support safety and engagement in care.

Limitations: Some of the evidence lacked details regarding specific settings, interventions or sample characteristics. This limits the extent to which findings can be applied to micro-level contexts. Stakeholder groups contributed key insights to the review at all stages. In spite of efforts to achieve diversity within these groups, there may have been experiences or identities that were missed.

Conclusions: Four 'CORE' implementation principles were identified to guide future practice and research: C - Creating the right environment, infrastructure and support for staff; O - Optimising consultations to be responsive, flexible and personalised to different needs and preferences; R - Recognising the importance of access and inclusion; and E - Enabling quality and safety through relationship-focused connections.

Future work: Future research should embed equity considerations and should focus on understanding digital clinical consultation within specific maternity systems (like triage/helplines), services (such as specialist outpatient clinics) or groups of women (e.g. with digital literacy or communication needs).

Funding: This synopsis presents independent research funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research as award number NIHR134535.

Keywords: EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS; MATERNAL HEALTH SERVICES; REALIST REVIEW; REMOTE CONSULTATION; TELEMEDICINE.