Penetrating neck wounds. Mandatory versus selective exploration

Abstract

We reviewed the records of 257 patients (ages, 16-83 years) with penetrating neck wounds (119 gunshot and 138 stab) managed at Harlem Hospital Center. Among the first 148 patients, 134 were managed by mandatory neck exploration; 42 had injuries (31%), and 92 (69%) had no injury. There were four deaths (3%) and seven (5%) morbidities. Because of the high rate of unnecessary operations, the following 109 patients were managed selectively, 40 by exploration, and nine of the 40 (22%) had no injury; 69 were observed and did not require subsequent operative intervention. There were six deaths (5.5%) and six morbidities (5.5%) among the second group. Morbidity and mortality were unrelated to the method of management but related to the type and severity of injuries, associated injuries, preexisting illnesses, and age of the patients. The frequency of operations for penetrating neck wounds without structural injuries was minimized in the selective exploration group.