Compatibility of Dual-Cure Core Materials with Self-Etching Adhesives

Abstract

Background/Objectives: A material incompatibility has been established between self-etching adhesives and amine-containing dual-cure resin composite materials used for core buildups. This study aims to compare the dentin bond strength of several amine-containing and amine-free core materials using self-etching adhesives with different pHs. Methods: Extracted human molars were mounted in acrylic and ground flat with 320-grit silicon carbide paper. Next, 520 specimens (n = 10/group) were assigned to a dual-cure core buildup material group (10 amine-containing, 2 amine-free, and 1 reference light-cure only bulk fill flowable composite) and assigned to a self-etching adhesive subgroup (pH levels of approximately 1.0, 3.0, and 4.0). Within 4 h of surface preparation, the adhesive corresponding to the specimen's subgroup was applied and light-cured. Composite buttons for the assigned dual-cure core material of each group were placed using a bonding clamp apparatus, allowed to self-cure for 2 h at 37 °C, and then unclamped. An additional group with one adhesive (pH = 3.0) was prepared in which the dual-cure core materials were light-cured. The bonded specimens were stored in water at 37 °C for 24 h. The specimens were mounted on a testing clamp and de-bonded in a universal testing machine with a load applied to a circular notched-edge blade at a crosshead speed of 1 mm/min until bond failure. The maximum load divided by the area of the button was recorded as the shear bond strength. The data was analyzed via 2-way ANOVA. Results: The analysis of bond strength via 2-way ANOVA determined statistically significant differences between the adhesives, the core materials, and their interaction (p < 0.01). There was a general trend in shear bond strength for the adhesives, where pH 4.0 > 3.0 > 1.0. The amine-free core materials consistently demonstrated higher shear bond strengths as compared to the other core materials when chemically cured only. Light-curing improved bond strength for some materials with perceived incompatibility. Conclusions: The results of this study suggest that an incompatibility can exist between self-etching adhesives and dual-cure resin composite core materials. A decrease in the pH of the utilized adhesive corresponded to a decrease in the bond strength of dual-cure core materials when self-curing. This incompatibility may be minimized with the use of core materials formulated with amine-free chemistry. Alternatively, the dual-cure core materials may be light-cured.

Keywords: core buildup; self-etch adhesive; shear bond strength; universal adhesive.

Figure 1

Ultradent shear bond strength apparatus (left); Button of core material bonded to the tooth specimen (center); Circular notched-edge blade for applying load to the button (right).

Figure 2

Example failure modes: Adhesive (top left), Cohesive within tooth (bottom left), Cohesive within core materials (top left), Cohesive within core and tooth (bottom right).

Figure 3

Shear bond strength (average ± standard deviation) of dual-cure resin composite core materials using different adhesive systems. * Light-cure only control group in which core was light-cured for all groups.