Current Evidence and Surgical Strategies in the Management of Greater Tuberosity Fracture-Dislocations: A Narrative Review

Abstract

Background: Greater tuberosity fracture-dislocations (GTFDs) represent a distinct subset of proximal humerus fractures, occurring in up to 57% of anterior glenohumeral dislocations. Malreduction may result in impingement, instability, and functional limitation. Treatment is influenced by the displacement magnitude and direction, bone quality, and patient activity level. Methods: This narrative review was based on a comprehensive search of PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science for English-language articles published between January 2000 and March 2025. Studies on pathomechanics, classification, diagnosis, treatment, and outcomes of GTFDs in adult and pediatric populations were included. Data were analyzed to summarize the current evidence and identify clinical trends. Results: A displacement ≥ 5 mm is the standard surgical threshold, though superior or posterosuperior displacement ≥ 3 mm-and ≥2 mm in overhead athletes-may justify surgery. Conservative treatment remains appropriate for minimally displaced fractures but is associated with up to 48% subacromial impingement and 11% delayed surgery. Surgical options include arthroscopic repair for small or comminuted fragments and open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) with screws or plates for larger, split-type fractures. Locking plates and double-row suture constructs demonstrate superior biomechanical performance compared with transosseous sutures. Reverse shoulder arthroplasty (RSA) is reserved for elderly patients with poor bone stock, cuff insufficiency, or severe comminution. Pediatric cases require physeal-sparing strategies. Conclusions: GTFDs management demands an individualized approach based on fragment displacement and direction, patient age and activity level, and bone quality. While 5 mm remains the common threshold, lower cutoffs are increasingly adopted in active patients. A tiered treatment algorithm integrating displacement thresholds, fracture morphology, and patient factors is proposed to support surgical decision making. The incorporation of fracture morphologic classifications further refines fixation strategy. Further prospective and pediatric-specific studies are needed to refine treatment algorithms and validate outcomes.

Keywords: arthroscopic fixation; greater tuberosity fracture; open fixation; proximal humerus; shoulder pain.

Figure 1

Illustration of the three types described by Mutch et al.: (A) avulsion type, (B) depression type, and (C) split type. Each subtype is associated with specific displacement patterns and fixation strategies.