Tuberculin sensitivity and skin lesions in children after vaccination with 11 different BCG strains

Abstract

In previously published studies, a number of BCG strains used in several production laboratories were compared in animal models. Liquid vaccines from the different strains were prepared in one laboratory with a uniform technique, the aim being to obtain uniform in vitro properties. In the studies reported here, such vaccines were compared by means of vaccinating children in India and Denmark and then measuring their post-vaccination skin lesions and tuberculin sensitivity. One strain induced delayed hypersensitivity strikingly weaker than that induced by any of the others, although the vaccine was in no way inferior in terms of exhaustive in vitro tests. Differences among the other strains were slight, although sometimes statistically significant. The implications of such differences are discussed.