Two controlled studies of the efficacy of isoniazid alone in preventing relapse in patients with bacteriologically quiescent pulmonary tuberculosis at the end of one year of chemotherapy

Abstract

An earlier report showed that, in patients with bacteriologically quiescent pulmonary tuberculosis at the end of 1 year of chemotherapy, isoniazid alone in a single daily dose of 150-200 mg, given as maintenance therapy in the second year, did not markedly prevent relapse over a 4-year period of follow-up in patients who had had residual cavitation (the "open-negative" syndrome) at 1 year, but was highly effective in patients who had not. As a result of these findings, two controlled studies, reported here, were undertaken.The first study was undertaken in patients with bacteriologically quiescent disease and residual cavitation at 1 year, and investigated the value of isoniazid in a higher daily dose (400 mg) throughout the second year; this is known to be the optimum therapeutic dose when isoniazid is prescribed alone for 1 year in the initial treatment of the disease. The second study was carried out in patients with bacteriologically quiescent disease and no residual cavitation at 1 year, and sought to determine the value of a shorter duration (6 months) of chemotherapy in the second year with a daily dose of 300 mg of isoniazid. Neither of the two isoniazid regimens was highly satisfactory, although both appeared to have had some effect in preventing relapse during the 4-year period of follow-up.