Comparison of Nissen fundoplication and Belsey Mark IV in the management of gastroesophageal reflux

Abstract

Our experience for the past four years with antireflux surgery has been reviewed. The Nissen fundoplication resulted in symptomatic improvement in 87.5 per cent of cases as compared with 64 per cent who were improved after the Belsey Mark IV procedure. Objective evaluation as measured by the standard acid reflux test (SART) revealed recurrent reflux in 9 per cent of those who underwent fundoplication and in 47 per cent of those treated with the Belsey repair. Mortality rates were similar. These results indicate that Nissen fundoplication is superior to the Belsey Mark IV procedure in the management of gastroesophageal reflux.