Influence of place of treatment on diagnosis, treatment, and survival in three pediatric solid tumors

Abstract

This study examines differences between cancer centers (CC) and noncancer centers (NCC) in terms of management procedures and outcomes for three pediatric solid tumors: Wilms' tumor (N = 147), rhabdomyosarcoma (N = 87), and medulloblastoma (N = 76). Data were derived for the period 1970-1979 from the population-based Greater Delaware Valley Pediatric Tumor Registry maintained at the Children's Cancer Research Center, which routinely collects data on all childhood neoplasms that occur in a 31-county region. Management measures reviewed included the degree to which important pretreatment evaluations were performed, types of therapy used, and extent of follow-up examinations conducted. Outcome variables were three-year disease-free survival and frequency of deaths related to complications of therapy. Differences in three-year disease-free survival between CC and NCC were noted for medulloblastoma (52% v 24%) and rhabdomyosarcoma (48% v 10%), but not for Wilms' tumor (79% v 68%). Among medulloblastoma patients, differences were detected in the frequency of pretreatment evaluations and in the therapy used. The principal management contrast found in rhabdomyosarcoma was that multiagent chemotherapy was used less often in NCC. Wilms' tumor patients were evaluated and treated similarly in the community versus the CC, except for some contrasts in the surgical approach and the frequency of follow-up for the detection of late complications.