Orchidectomy alone in testicular stage I non-seminomatous germ-cell tumours

Abstract

53 patients with clinical stage I non-seminomatous germ-cell testicular tumours were entered into a prospective study to receive no treatment other than orchidectomy until unequivocal clinical evidence of metastases was established. Of this group, 9 men (17%) have relapsed, 8 within six months of orchidectomy. All 9 are alive and disease-free after chemotherapy. The relapse rate was higher in patients with malignant teratoma undifferentiated (embryonal carcinoma) primary tumours than in those with malignant teratoma intermediate (teratocarcinoma); 42.8 and 3.4%, respectively. The results were compared with those from 157 men treated by orchidectomy and radiotherapy for stage I disease. In this group, 49 patients (25.8%) relapsed and 85% of relapses occurred within one year of orchidectomy. The tempo relapse was identical for embryonal carcinoma and teratocarcinoma. Of 32 patients in whom serum markers were measured before orchidectomy, 24 (75%) had raised levels of alphafetoprotein and/or beta human chorionic gonadotropin. These preliminary results imply that routine lymphadenectomy or lymph node irradiation in clinical state I testicular non-seminoma may be unjustifiable.