Small-cell carcinoma of the lung--survival according to histologic subtype: a Veterans Administration Lung Group Study

Abstract

Six-hundred-twenty cases of small-cell carcinoma of the lung entered into the Veterans Administration Lung Group protocols 9-15 were retrospectively subdivided into histologic subtype, as proposed by the WHO (1977). Medium survival was greater for subtype No. 21 (lymphocyte-like) than for subtype No. 22 (intermediate) (17.2 vs. 12.6 weeks; P = .005). Patients with extensive disease survived longer with subtype No. 21 than subtype No. 22 (14.5 vs. 10.9 weeks; P = .026). However, no median survival difference was seen with limited disease. Survival for subtype 21 was greater than No. 22 (P = .016) for patients with poor initial performance status (IPS; Karnofsky 70 or less); for ambulatory patients (IPS 80-100) a survival advantage was seen for subtype No. 21 compared with No. 22, but did not quite reach statistical significance (P = .09). Survival in subtype No. 21 was better than in subtype No. 22 (24.3 vs. 14.7 weeks; P = .001) when no weight loss (less than 10 pounds over the six-month period prior to therapy) was documented. However, with weight loss (greater than 10 pounds) survival in each subtype was similar.