Improved lung dose calculation using tissue-maximum ratios in the Batho correction

Abstract

We have reexamined the Batho power law for computing the dose within and beyond lung irradiated with small and large fields of cobalt-60 and 6-MV x rays. Using slab phantoms consisting of two materials, agreement between calculated and measured doses was within 2% inside lung for 6-MV x irradiation, but much poorer (9%) for cobalt-60 irradiation. For cobalt-60 irradiation, tissue-air ratios (TARs) were used initially in the Batho equation, while for 6-MV x rays, tissue-maximum ratios (TMRs) were used. When we substituted TMR values instead of TAR values for cobalt-60, we found marked improvement by nearly 5% in the accuracy of dose calculated within lung. This was confirmed by numerical comparison of the Batho expression with an analytic solution of the primary and first-scattered radiation. We therefore encourage the use of TMRs for cobalt-60 radiation, especially for larger radiation fields, and provide measured data tables for field sizes up to 50 X 50 cm2, and depths up to 30 cm. In addition to unifying the dosimetry for all megavoltage irradiation, this approach improves the accuracy of doses calculated within lung.