Equilibrium studies of lecithin-cholesterol interactions I. Stoichiometry of lecithin-cholesterol complexes in bulk systems

Abstract

The maximum molar ratio of lecithin:cholesterol in aqueous dispersions has been reported to be 2:1, 1:1, or 1:2. The source of the desparate results has been examined in this study by analyzing (a) the phase relations in anhydrous mixtures (from which most dispersions are prepared) and (b) various methods of preparing aqueous dispersions, with the purpose of avoiding the formation of metastable states that may be responsible for the variability of the lecithin-cholesterol stoichiometry. Temperature-composition phase diagrams for anhydrous mixtures of cholesterol (CHOL) with dimyristoyl (DML) and with dipalmitoyl (DPL) lecithin were obtained by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). Complexes form with molar ratios for lecithin:CHOL of 2:1 and 1:2; they are stable up to 70 degrees C. When x(CHOL) < 0.33, two phases coexist: complex (2:1) plus pure lecithin; when 0.33 < x(CHOL) < 0.67 complexes (2:1) and (1:2) coexist as separate phases. The corresponding phase diagram in water for these mixtures was determined by DSC and isopycnic centrifugation in D(2)O-H(2)O gradients. Aqueous dispersions were prepared by various methods (vortexing, dialysis, sonication) yielding identical results except as noted below. The data presented supports the following phase relations. When x(CHOL) < 0.33, two lipid phases coexist: pure lecithin plus complex (2:1) where the properties of the lecithin phase are determined by whether the temperature is below or above T(c), the gel-liquid crystal transition temperature. Therefore, complex (2:1) will coexist with gel state below T(c) and with liquid crystal above T(c). The densities follow in the order gel > complex (2:1) > liquid crystal. The density of complex (2:1) is less sensitive to temperature in the range 5 degrees -45 degrees C compared to the temperature dependence for DML and DPL where large changes in density occur at T(c). When x(CHOL) > 0.33, CHOL phase coexists with complex (2:1); anhydrous complex (1:2) is apparently not stable in H(2)O. The results are independent of the method and temperature used for preparing the lipid dispersions. However, when dispersions are prepared by sonication or with solvents at T > T(c), an apparent 1:1 complex is formed. Evidence suggests the 1:1 complex is metastable.