Controlled clinical trials of nutritional intervention as an adjunct to chemotherapy, with a comment on nutrition and drug resistance

Abstract

Nutritional intervention in the cancer patient [e.g., total parenteral nutrition (TPN)] might improve durable survival because of increased tolerance to aggressive tumor therapy. To determine whether this assumption is correct, 42 patients with diffuse histiocytic lymphoma were induced with prednisone, high-dose methotrexate, Adriamycin, cyclophosphamide, and VP-16 (ProMACE). Nitrogen mustard-vincristine-procarbazine-prednisone (MOPP) consolidation was then used, followed by late intensification with ProMACE. Patients were selected randomly to receive adjuvant TPN or a standard diet during ProMACE-MOPP treatment. While TPN patients had a greater median weight gain than did control patients, lean body mass and degree of myelosuppression did not improved as a consequence of TPN. There was no significant difference in tumor response or survival between TPN and control patients, whether or not the patients were initially malnourished. In a second trial, 32 young patients with metastatic or other poor-prognosis sarcomas were randomly allocated to receive TP or a standard diet as an adjunct to one very intensive course of combination chemotherapy or chemotherapy plus total body irradiation; autologous marrow transplantation was used with gain than did controls but remained in a negative nitrogen balance. Response rates and median durable survival did not differ between the two groups. In both trials, the maximum nutritional support permitted by currently available technology was offered. Thus, the limiting factor may not be nutritional status but rather the intrinsic biology of the tumors and the limitations of their response to current therapy. In in vitro studies of the possible influence of nutrition on cancer treatment, we have compared sublines of P388 murine leukemia cells which are sensitive or resistant to Adriamycin. The difference in drug sensitivity correlated with differences in lipid composition, with more intracellular lipid, and with greater membrane rigidity in the resistant cells. Resistant cells have a relatively poor transport of drug into the cell; moreover, intracellular Adriamycin is sequestered in lipid depots away from DNA. These results suggest one possible relationship between nutritional phenomena and drug sensitivity.