Randomized trial of conventional versus high fractional dose radiation therapy in the treatment of advanced head and neck cancer

Abstract

A prospectively randomized clinical trial was undertaken to compare conventionally fractionated radiation therapy and high fractional dose irradiation in the treatment of advanced, surgically unresectable head and neck squamous cell carcinoma. Sixty-four patients were entered into the study between 1973 and 1979 and were randomized to receive either 200 rad daily to total tumor doses of 6000-7000 rad in 6-7 weeks, or 400 rad daily to a total of approximately 4400 rad in 2-3 weeks. The distribution of patients between the two fractionation schedules was comparable regarding site of the primary tumor, extent of disease, degree of histologic differentiation and performance status. Twenty-nine of 31 (94%) patients in the 200 rad group and 29 of 33 (88%) in the 400 rad group has Stage IV disease. Twenty-six in the former group and 30 in the latter completed radiation therapy as planned. Acute skin and mucosal reactions occurred earlier in patients treated with 400 rad daily, but were of equivalent intensity and well within acceptable levels in both groups. No increase in late adverse effects was seen with high daily doses. Palliation of tumor-related symptoms and extent of tumor control were comparable in the two groups. Actuarial five year disease-free survival rates were approximately 10% in both treatment groups with a mean follow-up period of 5 1/2 years. We conclude that high fractional dose irradiation is equivalent to conventionally fractionated radiation therapy in the treatment of advanced head and neck cancer.