Randomized controlled trial of intraaortic balloon counterpulsation in early myocardial infarction with acute heart failure

Abstract

The value of intraaortic balloon counterpulsation in limiting infarct size and improving survival was studied in patients with early transmural myocardial infarction complicated by acute heart failure. Thirty such patients, previously well, were randomly assigned to counterpulsation (14 patients) or standard therapy (16 patients). Counterpulsation was begun 4.8 to 13.7 hours (mean 7.1) after the onset of pain and continued for less than 1 to 11 days (mean 4.5). Peak creatine kinase was 1,794 +/- 846 IU/liter (mean +/- standard deviation) in patients receiving counterpulsation compared with 1,688 +/- 908 for those receiving standard therapy; cumulative creatine kinase was 3,590 +/- 1,936 IU/liter for patients receiving counterpulsation and 2,945 +/- 1,803 for those receiving standard therapy. Hospital mortality was similar (counterpulsation, 7 of 14; standard therapy, 7 of 16 [p = 0.05 for 25 percent mortality reduction]) as was mortality at follow-up (counterpulsation, 8 of 14; standard therapy, 10 of 16 [p = 0.09 for 25 percent mortality reduction]). Functional class at follow-up examination 1 to 36 months (mean 15) after infarction was also similar in the two groups. Counterpulsation did not appear to modify infarct size or to alter morbidity or mortality when initiated as primary therapy 4.8 to 13.7 hours after the onset of symptoms of myocardial infarction.