A randomized prospective comparison of intermittent methotrexate, methotrexate with leucovorin, and a methotrexate combination in head and neck cancer

Abstract

A randomized prospective clinical trial involved 259 cases of advanced recurrent Stage III and IV epidermoid cancers of the head and neck. The cases were randomized among three treatment programs evaluating two dose schedules and a combination treatment of methotrexate. The treatments consisted of: weekly methotrexate, biweekly methotrexate with leucovorin rescue (ML), and biweekly ML combined with cyclophosphamide and cytosine arabinoside (MLCC). Equivalent overall drug-related toxicity was produced with a 5% drug-related fatality rate. Methotrexate alone produced significantly more skin and mucosal toxicity, and the combination (MLCC) resulted in more hematologic toxicity than other treatments. Complete and partial objective responses were achieved in 26%, 24%, and 18% by each treatment. Methotrexate alone produced a median duration of response and 105 days compared with 42 and 49 days from the other treatments. Duration of response was significantly longer and survival was better in the methotrexate-alone group. Response was markedly stage dependent; 40% of Stage III patients achieved response, whereas only 17% of Stage IV patients responded. Presence of visceral metastases decreased response rates and the likelihood of response was particularly compromised by pulmonary metastatic spread; only seven of 54 such patients responded. Decreased survival was related to non-ambulatory performance status, disease-free intervals of less than one year and weight loss. Survival differences between Stage III and IV patients could not be shown. This study demonstrates the therapeutic superiority of weekly i.v. treatment with methotrexate but failed to support claims of an improved therapeutic index for high-dose methotrexate with leucovorin rescue. As the only randomized prospective clinical trial of chemotherapy in advanced head and neck cancer, this study reinforces the weekly i.v. schedule of methotrexate as the standard against which other drug schedules and drug combinations should be compared.