A rationale for epidural analgesia in the treatment of multiple rib fractures

Abstract

Thoracic epidural analgesia (EA) is described as an alternative to controlled ventilation in patients presenting with multiple rib fractures. Lung mechanics were especially studied in 6 patients selected from a total of 49. The average ICU stay for this group was 4.5 days (2-11) and the mean age 55.7 years. The EA group was compared with 51 patients primarily ventilated who had an average stay in the ICU of 9.8 days and a mean age of 44.7 years. Mean number of rib fractures of the ventilated group at 6.5 was almost equal to the mean of 6.8 in the EA group. There was a difference in the number of associated fractures, 98 in the ventilated group compared to 35 in the EA group. Severe pulmonary and cerebral contusion were the two most important factors in enforcing the need to ventilate. The success of the method is evidenced by the increase in functional residual capacity (FRC), dynamic lung compliance (Cdyn), vital capacity (VC), the decrease of airway resistance (R) and a significantly increase of PaO2 (p less than 0,001) for the EA group with a balanced fluid therapy. All this accounts for the clinical observation of diminishing paradoxical movement of the flail segment.