Early-stage Hodgkin's disease: long-term results with radiotherapy alone or combined radiotherapy and chemotherapy

Abstract

Background: Controversy still exists over the optimal management of early-stage Hodgkin's disease (HD); presentation features may have a different prognostic impact according to initial therapy, and long-term toxicity must be fully evaluated.

Patients and methods: This study included 164 patients with stage IA-IIA HD treated with radiotherapy (RT) alone or combined radio- and chemotherapy (CT) according to presenting features and their attendant prognostic significance. The RT group included 88 patients with favorable prognostic features; the combined modality group included 76 patients with one or more unfavorable features. In the RT group, 85% of patients received extended-mantle or STNI; in the combined modality group, RT consisted of mantle- (49%), extended mantle- (37%), and involved-field irradiation (14%); CT consisted of 6 cycles of MOPP before 1984; 3 cycles of ABVD were substituted for MOPP thereafter.

Results: Complete remission was obtained in 94% and 99% of patients of the RT and combined modality groups, respectively. The 10-year actuarial relapse-free survival (RFS) in the RT group was 62% and was influenced by stage (p = 0.04) and histology (p = 0.01); in the combined modality group, RFS was 88% and was influenced by the presence of bulky disease. Overall survival and tumor mortality between the therapy groups were comparable. RT-related toxicity consisted of mediastinal fibrosis (8 cases), myelitis (3), hypothyroidism (2); other long-term events included 2 cases of acute leukemia in the combined MOPP and RT group. Altogether, 8 of 20 patients who died were in their first complete remission.

Conclusions: In stage IA-IIA HD, the combined modality therapy reduced the risk of relapse compared to radiation alone; long-term toxicity of RT was not negligible and relapses could occur late.