Definition of local recurrence after surgery for rectal carcinoma

Abstract

Local recurrence rates of rectal carcinoma have been analysed among 284 patients in a prospective randomized multicentre trial of adjuvant preoperative radiotherapy for locally advanced rectal carcinoma. Wide variations in local recurrence rates are demonstrated depending on the definition of local recurrence employed and the subgroup studied. Thus after surgical operation alone, rates as high as 43.3 per cent or as low as 12.7 per cent can be calculated. After both adjuvant preoperative radiotherapy and operation the overall local recurrence rate is 12.8 per cent, although the local recurrence rate inside the radiotherapy field (true recurrence) may be as low as 2.3 per cent. It is recommended that local recurrence after operation for rectal carcinoma be defined as any detectable local disease at follow-up, occurring either alone or in conjunction with generalized recurrence, in patients who have undergone resection. A rate should be given both for all patients and for those operated on for cure, but not for the latter group alone as this could introduce bias.