Comparison of efficacies of famciclovir and valaciclovir against herpes simplex virus type 1 in a murine immunosuppression model

Abstract

A mouse model of herpes simplex virus type 1 infection in an immunocompromised host was established by using cyclosporin-A to impair T-cell function. Following inoculation of herpes simplex virus type 1 into the skin of the ear pinna, cyclosporin-A prolonged virus replication in the skin and neural tissues compared with that in immunocompetent mice. This model was used to investigate the activity of famciclovir (FCV) and valaciclovir (VACV), which are oral products of the antiherpesvirus agents penciclovir and acyclovir, respectively. Both prodrugs gave similar blood profiles of the antiherpesvirus agents in normal and cyclosporin-treated mice. The compounds were administered by the oral route at 50 mg/kg per dose twice daily for 5 days. Both compounds were very effective at clearing infectious virus from the tissues despite the immunosuppression; FCV-treated animals cleared virus from the ear pinna more rapidly than VACV-treated animals. The areas under the concentration-time curve (AUC) for virus replication with time were reduced to 50 and 30% of control values for ear pinna and brain stem, respectively, with VACV therapy and to < 5% in both tissues by FCV. When treatment was continued to day 10, the reductions in AUC for ear and brain stem, respectively, were to 33 and 26% of control values with VACV and to < 3 and < 5% with FCV. However, on cessation of the antiviral treatment, there was a reproducible recurrence of infectious virus in the tissues obtained from VACV-treated mice. The recurrence of infectious virus was also evident after 10 days of treatment with VACV. In mice which had received FCV for 10 or 5 days, these was no resumption of virus replication in the ear pinna or brain stem. When dosing was reduced to once per day, both compounds were less effective at controlling the infection. Nevertheless, no recurrence of infectious virus was observed on cessation of FCV therapy.