Analysis of meningiomas by methylation- and transcription-based clonality assays

Abstract

The clonal derivation of tumors can be determined by X chromosome inactivation analysis based on differential expression of genes or differential methylation of cytosine residues in CpG islands near polymorphic loci. In this report, we compared a transcription-based RNA analysis with a methylation-based DNA assay to determine clonality of meningiomas. Both clonality assays use PCR-based analysis at the hunan androgen-receptor gene (HUMARA) on the X chromosome. Among 23 meningiomas from female patients, 19 were informative heterozygotes at this locus (83%). The patterns of X chromosome inactivation in four patients were extremely skewed towards one allele in blood (unequal Lyonization), which precluded clonality determination in the tumor samples. Concordant clonality results with methylation- and transcription-based clonality assays were demonstrated in 9 of 13 informative tumors expressing the androgen receptor. Seven meningiomas were monoclonal, but surprisingly, two pathologically documented cases of meningiomas were polyclonal. There was disparity in 4 of 13 tumor specimens that were polyclonal by the methylation-based assay but monoclonal by the transcription assay. Clonality examination of these tumors by the methylation-based phosphoglycerate kinase assay provided identical results to the methylation-based analysis at the HUMARA locus. In addition, loss of heterozygosity (LOH) studies of chromosome 22, which is frequently deleted in meningiomas, showed that four of four informative samples of the six polyclonal tumors had partial LOH in tumor tissues. However, complete LOH was observed in primary cultured cells, which were also monoclonal by the methylation assay. Taken together, these data suggest that the disparity of the two assays in these four cases may be due to differences in the level of expression of the androgen receptor gene in tumors. Therefore, we conclude that: (a) clonal derivation of meningiomas determined by both transcription- and methylation-based clonality assays are in full agreement in many (9 of 13) but not all cases (4 of 13); and (b) most meningiomas (9 of 15) are monoclonal in origin, whereas some meningioma samples (6 of 15) are polyclonal or may contain heterogeneous components.