Reliability of the anterior drawer test, the pivot shift test, and the Lachman test

Abstract

In 147 patients with arthroscopically proved chronic injuries of the anterior cruciate ligament, the anterior drawer test, the Lachman test, and the pivot shift test were done before operation under general or spinal anesthesia. Results of the anterior drawer test were positive in 79.6% of the patients, in 98.6% patients having the Lachman test, and in 89.8% of patients having the pivot shift test. In 19 cases (12.9%), arthroscopic examination showed reattachment of the proximally torn end of the anterior cruciate ligament to the posterior cruciate ligament. In these cases, results of the anterior drawer test were positive in 13 patients (68.4%), in 17 (89.5%) patients having the Lachman test, and in 12 patients (63.2%) having the pivot shift test. In 15 cases with a false negative pivot shift test, arthroscopy showed blockage of anterior subluxation of the lateral tibial condyle by a partially functioning portion of the anterior cruciate ligament, which was reattached to the posterior cruciate ligament in 7 cases. In 2 cases with a false negative Lachman test, there was firm reattachment of the torn end of the anterior cruciate ligament to the proximal portion of the posterior cruciate ligament combined with a bucket handle tear of the medial meniscus. The Lachman test was most sensitive in diagnosing chronic injuries of the anterior cruciate ligament. The pivot shift test was also sensitive but was influenced by many factors.