Bacteriology of urinary tract stones

Abstract

It has been reported that up to half of renal stones and associated urine specimens have been positive on culture, and that up to 50% of such stones contain magnesium ammonium phosphate. In a prospective study using infrared and wet chemical analysis, we found positive cultures in only 7 of 132 renal, 5 of 105 ureteral and 6 of 21 bladder stones obtained surgically and handled with sterility. Of the culture positive calculi only 43% from the kidney, none from the ureter and 50% from the bladder contained detectable magnesium ammonium phosphate. However, magnesium ammonium phosphate was detectable in 20% of renal, 2% of ureteral and 27% of bladder stones with negative cultures. Of the culture positive renal and ureteral calculi 42% were predominantly calcium phosphate and 17% were predominantly calcium oxalate. For culture negative stones 25% and 51% from the kidney, and 15% and 82% from the ureter were composed of predominantly calcium phosphate and calcium oxalate, respectively. Among the culture positive stones, related positive urine cultures were noted in 100% of the renal, 20% of the ureteral and 50% of the bladder cases, compared to 26%, 10% and 27%, respectively, of culture negative calculi. The same organism was found in the stone and urine in only 38% of the cases. The lower frequency of positive urine cultures, of stones with magnesium ammonium phosphate, and especially of culture positive renal and ureteral stones (5%) than in previous reports suggests that stone culture may be of less value than indicated previously, except for bladder calculi and large renal stones, such as the branched type.