Comparison of changes in bone mineral in idiopathic and secondary osteoporosis following therapy with cyclical disodium etidronate and high dose calcium supplementation

Abstract

Objective: Our clinical practice has been to offer treatment with cyclical disodium etidronate and high dose calcium supplements (1500-1600 mg/day) to all female patients with osteoporosis who are unable or unwilling to take hormone replacement therapy (HRT), and male osteoporotics. In a retrospective study we compared the effect of this treatment on measures of bone mineral over a 12-month period in women with post-menopausal and secondary osteoporosis. We also assessed its effects in 10 male osteoporotics.

Design: A retrospective analysis of 83 consecutive patients with osteoporosis who completed 12 months of treatment with disodium etidronate and calcium and who had a dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) scan at baseline and following 12 months of therapy.

Patients: The study included 73 women (45 post-menopausal and 28 secondary osteoporotics) and 10 men with established osteoporosis as shown by spinal and femoral bone mineral densities (BMD) > 2 standard deviations (SD) below young normals, and radiological evidence of osteoporosis.

Measurements: Each patient had routine biochemistry at baseline, an X-ray of thoracic and lumbar spine and a DEXA scan of lumbar spine (L2-L4) and femoral neck. The DEXA scan was repeated following 12 months of therapy.

Results: There was no difference between increase in spinal BMD in the post-menopausal (5.7%) versus secondary osteoporotic group (6.7%). There was a significant increase in spinal BMD at 12 months in the 10 male osteoporotics (9.0%, P < 0.01). No overall change in femoral neck BMD was noted.

Conclusions: Cyclical disodium etidronate given with high dose calcium supplements is equally effective in increasing spinal bone mineral density in post-menopausal and secondary osteoporosis. It also results in a significant rise in spinal bone mineral density in male osteoporotics. Whether this produces a reduction in fracture rates is unknown.