Diagnostic power of lecithin/sphingomyelin ratio and fluorescence polarization assays for respiratory distress syndrome compared by relative operating characteristic curves

Abstract

Amniotic fluids from 328 patients were analyzed for lecithin/sphingomyelin (L/S) ratio and surfactant/albumin (S/A) ratio by fluorescence polarization. Of this group, 61 neonates showed respiratory distress syndrome (RDS) on delivery within 3 days of testing. We compared the power of the L/S and S/A in diagnosing pulmonary maturity, using relative operating characteristic (ROC) curves. The area defined by the ROC curve of the S/A test exceeded the area defined by the L/S curve, but this difference was not statistically significant. The diagnostic power of the S/A test appears to be at least equal to that of the standard L/S test. A review of five cases of RDS in which laboratory tests had suggested maturity showed that neither the L/S nor the S/A could satisfactorily resolve the problem of false interpretations of maturity, particularly in mothers with diabetes mellitus who underwent cesarean section.