[Recombinant vaccine and extracting vaccine against hepatitis B in patients with kidney insufficiency: comparative immunogenicity]

Abstract

Objectives: Patients with chronic renal failure respond rather poorly to hepatitis B vaccines. A better response could be expected from recombinant vaccines including both the S and the pre-S2 antigens. We therefore prospectively compared the immunogenicity of plasma-derived Hevac B vaccine (H) with that of recombinant GenHevac B vaccine (G).

Methods: Vaccinations were performed in 120 non-dialyzed patients with chronic renal failure. The patients were randomly divided into two groups. Group G included 60 patients (24 males, mean age 58 +/- 16 years, mean creatinine clearance 25.3 +/- 12.6 ml/min) who were given the Hevac B vaccine at the dose of 5 micrograms. Group H included 60 patients (31 males, mean age 60 +/- 15 years, mean creatinine clearance 24.4 +/- 11.1 ml/min) who were given GenHevac B vaccine at the dose of 20 micrograms. All vaccinations were repeated at 0, 1, 2, 4 and 12 months.

Results: Following the fourth injection, seroconversion (anti-Hbs > or = 2 mlU/ml) was observed in 50/59 (85%) of the patients in group G versus 38/58 (67%) in group H (p < 0.02). Seroprotection (> or = 10 mlU/ml) was obtained in 42/59 (71%) vs 34/58 (59%), (NS) in the two groups respectively with a geometric mean titer of 112 versus 229 mlU/ml (NS) in responders. Following the booster injection at the 12th month, seroconversion was achieved in 48/51 (94%) vs 40/53 (76%) (p < 0.01) and seroprotection in 84% vs 70% (p = 0.053) respectively. The mean geometric titers were 879 and 1001 mlU/ml.

Conclusions: Recombinant GenHevac B vaccine elicits seroconversion and seroprotection in a higher proportion of patients with chronic renal failure than the plasma-derived Hevac B vaccine, with comparably high antibody titers in responders. Therefore, GenHevac B vaccine should be recommended for vaccinating patients with chronic renal failure against hepatitis B.