The shear strength and the failure mode of plasma-sprayed hydroxyapatite coating to bone: the effect of coating thickness

Abstract

Plasma-sprayed hydroxyapatite coated (HAC) 50 and 200 microns thick on Ti-6Al-4V cylinders was transcortically implanted in the femora of canines to evaluate in detail the effect of coating thickness on the pushout shear strength and failure mode examined under scanning electron microscope after the periods of 4, 6, 8, and 12 weeks. The HAC coating exhibited higher shear strength at 50 microns than at 200 microns. Its failure mode was conclusively at or near the HAC-bone interface, and the slight attack of body fluid had not degraded the implant to the extent that failure occurred at the HAC-Ti alloy interface after 12 weeks of observation. For 200 microns-HAC, failure was found at the HAC-bond interface, inside the HAC lamellar splat layer and at the HAC-Ti alloy substrate interface, depending on the period of implantation. It was also deduced that the variation of failure mode of 200 microns-HAC with time could not be accounted for by the attack of body fluid alone; the degradation must be a synergetic adverse result of residual stress in the HAC and the attack of body fluid.