Patterns of dystonia ("I-D-I" and "D-I-D-") in response to l-dopa therapy for Parkinson's disease

Abstract

The clinical, biochemical, and pharmacologic responses to L-dopa were studied in 87 patients with Parkinson's disease. Eleven of the 87 patients had a long-duration response, 39 had a short-duration response, and 37 had a combination of both. Thirty-four of the 39 patients with short-duration response to L-dopa experienced a consistent and reproducible sequence of clinical and biochemical events after each dose, characterized by improvement of parkinsonism and a single phase of dystonia occurring during or shortly after the peak of dopa concentration in plasma and during maximal clinical improvement. We have called this the I-D-I- response, for Parkinsonism-Improvement-Dystonia-Improvement-Parkinsonism. The remaining five patients all had the onset of the disease at an unusually young age and showed a distinctly different response pattern consisting of a first phase of dystonia, before there was any improvement, followed by a phase of improvement without dystonia and then by a second phase of dystonia before the abrupt return of parkinsonism. We have called this the D-I-D response, for Parkinsonism-Dystonia-Improvement-Dystonia-Parkinsonsim. Dystonia occurs in the D-I-D- response when the concentration of dopa in plasma passes through a critical but relatively low level, whereas it remains absent as long as the concentration of dopa remains above that level. In the I-D-I- response, dystonia is avoided by keeping the plasma concentration of dopa low, in the D-I-D- response by keeping it high. It is postulated that in the D-I-D response postsynaptic depolarization blockade due to supramaximal stimulation of the neuronal system mediating dystonia occurs, whereas in the I-D-I response the postsynaptic members of the same neuronal population respond with excitation but not with depolarization blockade.