Ventilation-perfusion lung scanning and spiral computed tomography of the lungs: competing or complementary modalities?

Abstract

The recently developed technique of spiral computed tomographic angiography (CTA) is being used for the detection of pulmonary emboli (PE), and several studies have assessed its accuracy using pulmonary angiography as the gold standard. CTA shows a high level of accuracy in the detection of pulmonary emboli in segmental or larger central vessels. The specificity is high enough to eliminate the requirement for angiography if a positive CTA result is found. The main factor limiting the sensitivity of CTA is the frequency of peripheral emboli in the vessels outside the central chest field covered by CTA. The incidence of such peripheral emboli varies in different reports from 0% to 36%, and their significance remains arguable. Interpretative criteria for V./Q.- lung scintigraphy have been refined as a result of the lessons learned from the PIOPED study. Using these modified criteria, and taking into account the prior probability of PE based on the presence or absence of clinical risk factors, treatment decisions can be reasonably made in patients in the following categories: those with normal lung scans, those with high probability scans and high prior probability of PE, and those with low probability scans and low clinical suspicion. Patients with intermediate probability or indeterminate scans, and those in whom the scan results conflict with the clinical expectation, will need further tests. Ultrasound examination of the leg veins, if positive, will select a further subgroup of patients for active treatment. Patients with a negative or inconclusive ultrasound result, who previously have been candidates for pulmonary angiography, can now go on to CTA. The advantages in specificity which CTA offers will make it an important part of the diagnostic workup for selected patients, but in view of its increased cost and high radiation dose compared with V./Q. scintigraphy, the argument that CTA should completely replace lung scintigraphy is currently unsupportable.