Comparison of two monoclonal antibodies for the detection of estrogen receptors in primary breast carcinomas

Abstract

A new monoclonal antibody against estrogen receptor (ID5, Dako) has shown promising results when applied to formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissue. In order to determine whether this antibody can compete in specificity and sensitivity with the ER-ICA antibody (Abbott Laboratories), a comparative, prospective study of the two antibodies was carried out on paraffin embedded and fresh frozen tissue in three laboratories. Two hundred and fifteen breast carcinomas were examined. Formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissue was available from 215 tumors, and fresh frozen tissue from 189 of the tumors. Of these, 124 tumors were also investigated by the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The results from each of the three laboratories correspond with those obtained for the whole material. The percentage of tumors positive for estrogen receptors within the different methods, was as follows: 71% by ID5 on paraffin sections, 50% by ER-ICA on paraffin sections, 65% ER-ICA on frozen sections and 88% by the EIA. When comparing the different immunohistochemical results and the EIA in 2 x 2 tables, agreement was reached in 69% to 91% of the cases. The best agreement (91%) was found between results obtained with the ID5 antibody used on formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissue and the ER-ICA kit used on fresh frozen tissue. The advantages of using the ID5 antibody are associated with its applicability to formalin fixed, paraffin embedded tissue: improved morphology, reproducibility, retrospective studying and low costs. Finally, it is reproducible not only within the same laboratory but also among different laboratories.