[Cruciate ligament injuries with knee joint effusion--why can the Lachman sign not be elicited?]

Abstract

In acute anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) lesions with effusion of the knee joint it is often difficult to realize a positive Lachman sign. It was suggested that the tension of the joint capsule may reduce tibial displacement although the ACL is completely disrupted. In 10 cadaver knee joints the ACL was dissected and the capsule was closed again. By a canula the knee joints were filled with isotonic saline solution in steps of 20 ml up to 100 ml. Before and after dissection of the ACL and during filling the joint we measured the anterior tibial displacement by use of the MEDmetric KT 1000 arthrometer. In a second series we examined 5 patients with acute effusion of the knee joint before and after puncture of the effusion. We detected the electromyographic activity of the quadriceps muscle end and the hamstrings during the KT 1000 test and patellar reflex. In the cadaver tests we found no reduction of the anterior tibial translation while filling the joint with saline solution. The electromyographic examinations showed a reflectory action in the quadriceps muscle and in the hamstrings when the Lachman test was performed. In the quadriceps muscle the electromyographic amplitude was reduced after puncture; the hamstrings showed a drastically reduced amplitude and duration of the signal. When patellar reflex was performed we recorded an electromyographic action in both muscle groups, too. Puncture could only reduce the signals of the hamstrings. Our results suggest that the reduction of the anterior drawer and the Lachman test in acute effusion is caused not mechanically by the tension of the capsule but by a reflectory muscle action of the hamstrings.