Excision and anastomotic repair for urethral stricture disease: experience with 150 cases

Abstract

Purpose: To analyze the results of a series of end-to-end urethroplasties performed in our service from 1968 to 1995 and of the factors contributing to failure.

Material and methods: 150 men (mean age 35.9 years) with urethral stricture disease underwent excision of the stricture and end-to-end anastomosis; in 95 it was the first attempt at repair while in 55 it was a secondary attempt. Eighty-two patients (54.6%) had a trauma-related stricture; of them, 56 followed a pelvic ring fracture with posterior urethra distraction defect, 24 (16%) had inflammatory strictures, 26 (17.3%) iatrogenic, 9 (6%) congenital, and 9 (6%) of unknown etiology; 81 (54%) were located in the bulbous urethra, 9 (6%) in the penoscrotal junction and 2 (1.3%) in the penile urethra. Ninety-one (60.6%) of the strictures or obliterative defects measured between 1 and 3 cm, 42 (28%) less than 1 cm and only 16 (10.6%) more than 3 cm. A perineal approach was used in 138 of the cases, while combined abdominoperineal route was necessary in 12; of these, 5 were children. The follow-up has ranged from 6 to 168 months (mean 44.4). The results were classified as good, fair (some re-stricturing, not needing treatment) and poor (recurrence).

Results: One hundred and twenty-six (84%) good outcomes, 10 (6.6%) fair, 14 (9.3%) poor. The factors influencing success or failure were: (1) primary or secondary character of the operation; (2) etiology; (3) length, and (4) location. Postoperative early complications consisted of 2 wound infections and 2 hematomas; as late complications, 1 chordee, 2 incontinence, 7 erectile dysfunction (in previously potent patients). The 14 patients considered as failures were operated again, all successfully; in 4 of them, a repeat excision and end-to-end anastomosis was performed, elevating the final success rate of the series to 93.3%.

Conclusion: Excision and anastomotic repair represent the optimal mode of stricture repair for single lesions located from the penoscrotal junction to the membranous part of the urethra.