The fate of intraperitoneally retained gallstones with different morphologic and microbiologic characteristics: an experimental study

Abstract

Management of intraperitoneally retained gallstones after laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) is controversial, as their natural course is not known. This study was undertaken to assess the probable effects of stone morphology and clinically obvious infection on the outcome of retained gallstones in a mouse model. Forty albino mice were divided into four groups. Group I served as the control group (simple laparotomy, n = 10). Groups II, III, and IV (n = 10 in each group) were study groups. "Intact-sterile-cholesterol" (group II), "crushed-sterile-cholesterol" (group III), and "intact" (n = 5) [group IVa] and "crushed" (n = 5) [group IVb] "infected-cholesterol" gallstones aseptically retrieved from three different human patients were implanted to the peritoneal cavity of the animals. Group IV animals were implanted with stones retrieved from an acutely inflamed gallbladder with proven infection. Animals were sacrificed 6 and 12 weeks after the operations. Cultures and tissue samples were obtained. No animal was lost, no microscopic or macroscopic abnormality was observed in groups I and II, and cultures remained negative. In group III, adhesions surrounding the fragmented stones were evident at the 12th week, and no mortality was encountered. The histopathology revealed a fibroblastic reaction, and cultures remained negative in group III. In group IV, three animals from group IVb and one animal from group IVa died because of intra-abdominal sepsis before their sacrifice. All remaining mice showed severe adhesions with localized abscesses at the 12th week. In conclusion, intraperitoneally retained cholesterol gallstones remain inert and do not cause serious peritoneal reaction unless they are crushed into fragments or are from an acutely inflamed gallbladder. It is for this group of patients that laparotomy for total stone clearance is probably not justifiable. Better stone retrieval techniques or even laparotomy may be worthwhile considering in patients with crushed and particularly infected retained stones.