Radiotherapeutic management of bulky cervical lymphadenopathy in squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck: is postradiotherapy neck dissection necessary?

Abstract

Although traditional recommendations for the management of bulky cervical lymphadenopathy (AJCC categories N2-3) with definitive radiotherapy call for postradiotherapy neck dissection regardless of treatment response, recent data suggests that this policy can be modified on the basis of tumor regression rate. In a series of 130 patients with stage III-IV squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck managed with a concomitant boost-accelerated hyperfractionated radiotherapy schedule, 81 cases had cervical lymphadenopathy at the time of referral. Patients were analyzed with respect to regional control outcomes for those having complete and incomplete clinical responses during the initial 3-month follow-up interval. The general management policy has been close observation of patients demonstrating complete clinical responses to radiation rather than postradiotherapy neck dissection. Failure patterns were examined in the 58 patients classified as complete responders. Failure occurred in the primary site in 16 (28%) of these patients, while isolated neck failure occurred in only 3 (5%). Neck recurrence rates for patients with maximum lymph node size < or = 3 cm vs. > 3 cm were not statistically different at 3-year follow-up (94% vs. 86%). Among the 23 incomplete clinical responders, 18 had incomplete neck responses. Five of these patients underwent salvage neck dissection; 4 remain clinically free of recurrence. The remaining 13 patients who either refused or were not eligible for salvage surgery ultimately succumbed with persistent loco-regional disease. The policy of observation after complete response to the radiotherapy schedule employed here was associated with a very low incidence of isolated neck failures and was safe and appropriate in patients who can be followed reliably. The prognosis for patients who failed to respond in the neck was poor except for those who underwent salvage surgery.