Auditory attentional shifts in reading-disabled students: quantification of attentional effectiveness by the Attentional Shift Index

Abstract

A controversy has existed for some years regarding auditory attentional skills in reading-disabled children. Data have suggested highly developed attentional skills in groups of reading-disabled students, but reduced attentional shifts have also been documented in equivalent groups. Attentional shifts in dichotic listening with forced or directed attention are usually inferred from a significant interaction between attentional task and ear. However, this procedure cannot be used to evaluate individual test performance, and the interaction does not give a useful measure of attentional shifts in dichotic listening meaningful for comparison with other tests of attention. In this paper attentional shifts in dichotic listening are quantified with the Attentional Shift Index (ASI), a measure for evaluating the degree of attentional shift in individual subjects. The ASI is based on the log-odds ratio of hits and intrusion errors when the subject has been tested under conditions of directed or forced attention. When 58.3% of the normative sample showed significant attentional shifts, none of the reading-disabled sample did so. This finding is discussed in relation to different types of deficits that can account for for the lack of auditory attentional shifts.