Elbow valgus stress radiography in an uninjured population

Abstract

Valgus instability of the elbow joint is a clinical diagnosis. However, many authors describe valgus stress radiographs as an aid in making this diagnosis. We studied valgus stress radiographs of 20 men (40 elbows) and 20 women (40 elbows), none with a history of elbow trauma or instability. The medial ulnohumeral distance was measured with no stress, valgus stress by gravity, and an applied valgus stress of 25 N (approximately 5 pounds). Measurements were made with the elbow positioned in extension and in 30 degrees of flexion. The increase in medial ulnohumeral gapping with either gravity or 5 pounds of stress was statistically significant at both extension and 30 degrees of flexion compared with the unstressed condition. The difference in ulnohumeral gapping between gravity stress and 5 pounds of valgus stress in extension and in 30 degrees of flexion was also significant. We found no differences with regard to hand dominance or sex. We conclude that uninjured elbows have significant medial ulnohumeral gapping on valgus stress radiography. Although this is an important tool in diagnosing valgus instability of the elbow, it may yield a false-positive assessment of valgus instability. Valgus stress radiographs comparing contralateral elbows may reduce the false-positive rate since there appears to be no significant difference in medial ulnohumeral gapping between the two elbows.