Devic's neuromyelitis optica: a clinicopathological review of the literature in connection with a case showing fatal dysautonomia

Abstract

A new clinicopathological case of Devic's neuromyelitis optica, including unusual predominant clinical features (fatal dysautonomia) is described herein: pathological examination showed extensive and severe demyelination mainly involving the optic nerves, the medulla, and spinal cord, which was particularly pronounced in the thoracic segments, and thus explained the unusual vegetative symptomatology. In a review of 45 clinicopathological cases described in the literature as Devic's disease (DD), it turned out that only 22 cases, including the patient described here, fulfilled the recently defined diagnostic criteria [Devic 1980]. Among the other 23 cases, 15 did not fulfill the criteria because of the occurrence of relapses, 3 others had 2 separate pathological locations within the spinal cord, and the remaining 5 showed evidence that a disease other than DD was involved. Among the 22 cases which were definitely taken to be DD, the mean age at clinical onset was 39 years (+/- 14); it was characterized by acute bilateral visual loss and transversal myelitis which gradually led either to death or to partial or complete recovery. The pathological lesions, which mostly were located along the optic tracts and the spinal cord, were characterized by demyelination with inflammation and necrosis; in some cases the pathological process diffused into the medulla (8/22 cases) or the whole brainstem (4/22 cases). The cavitation of the spinal cord was not a key feature of the diagnosis, since it was observed on only 9/22 cases. Devic's neuromyelitis optica may be a separate nosological entity which differs from multiple sclerosis.