The management and clinical course of testicular seminoma: 15 years' experience at a single institution

Abstract

Testicular seminoma is one of the most curable solid neoplasms, with 5-year survival rates in excess of 90%. However, controversy persists around its optimum management, particularly for Stage I disease. The outcome of 314 patients with testicular seminoma who were treated at a single institution is reported. A comparison of adjuvant radiotherapy and surveillance for Stage I is presented, and the possible prognostic influence of an elevated serum beta-human chorionic gonadotrophin (beta hCG) is assessed. The 5-year disease-free survival for all stages of presentation was 95.5%. There were more relapses in Stage I patients undergoing surveillance (14/94, 15%) than postorchidectomy radiotherapy (6/144, 4%; P = < 0.05). However, survival was identical irrespective of treatment policy, with no disease-related deaths in either group of Stage I patients. There were eight tumour-related deaths from advanced disease and 14 deaths from non-tumour causes. Three were due to cardiorespiratory disease, four to an unrelated second malignancy, two from infection and one from suicide; in four patients, the cause was unknown. Preoperative beta hCG was elevated in 29 (18%) of Stage I patients and in 24 (62%) of those presenting with Stage II disease. Patients were more likely to have advanced disease (> or = Stage II) if beta hCG was elevated (P < 0.001). Neither disease-free nor overall survival were influenced by the preoperative level of beta hCG. Surveillance appears to be a safe alternative to postorchidectomy radiotherapy for Stage I disease, provided the patient is prepared for intensive long term follow-up. An increased risk of relapse, but not of tumour death, can be expected and unnecessary treatments avoided.