Comparison of virtual and fiberoptic bronchoscopy

Abstract

Preoperative diagnostic procedures in the treatment of non-small-cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC) include fiberbronchoscopy (FBS) and CT scanning of the thorax and abdomen. The introduction of double-detector helical computed tomography has led to improved image resolution which allows three-dimensional reconstruction of the bronchial tree. A special computer simulation provides a virtual endoscopic view into the inner surface of the bronchial system. In order to determine whether the so-called virtual bronchoscopy (VBS) accurately reflects the anatomic situation of the bronchial tree, neoplastic lesion, and postoperative control of sleeve resections, we performed a virtual bronchoscopy in 24 patients with NSCLC and in 6 patients following sleeve resections and compared the results with the findings of fiberoptic bronchoscopy. An anatomic computer simulation of the bronchial tree was created in 100% of the investigated patients. Central tumor stenosis or occlusion was visualized by VBS as well as by FBS. In peripheral tumorous lesions VBS revealed the correct diagnosis in only 75%. VBS, however, enables viewing beyond the stenosis. FBS remains the gold standard in the endoscopic diagnostic procedures, showing not only airway patency but also mucosal changes in the vicinity of the tumorous lesion. VBS, however, gives further information about the poststenotic area in occlusive main bronchus stenosis. Furthermore, adequate control investigation of airway patency in patients following sleeve resections or stent implantation can be performed by VBS.